Talent.com
Auto Insurance Claims Manager
Auto Insurance Claims ManagerAmerican Freedom Insurance Company • Mount Prospect, IL, US
Auto Insurance Claims Manager

Auto Insurance Claims Manager

American Freedom Insurance Company • Mount Prospect, IL, US
job_description.job_card.variable_hours_ago
serp_jobs.job_preview.job_type
  • serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
job_description.job_card.job_description

Job Description

Job Description

Auto Insurance Claims Manager

Location :  Mount Prospect, IL (Hybrid preferred, remote available)

Salary :  $90,000 – $120,000

About AFIC :

American Freedom Insurance Company (AFIC) is a fast-growing, A+ Superior-rated nonstandard auto insurer operating in Illinois, Indiana, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, and Texas. We are committed to excellence, customer care, and empowering employees to thrive.

What You'll Be Doing :

As our Claims Manager, you will lead and shape the success of our claims department, focusing on efficiency, cost control, and exceptional service. Experience handling Private Passenger Auto (PPA) claims in Indiana and Pennsylvania is preferred, while overall claims workload management covers IL, IN, TN, PA, and TX :

  • Lead & Empower Your Team :  Manage and motivate claims staff with focus on IN and PA claims teams, ensuring workflow, workload, and service levels are met efficiently.
  • Optimize Processes :  Develop strategies to reduce loss costs and ensure efficient claim processing
  • Drive Performance :  Set and measure performance indicators to ensure accountability and team success.
  • Regulatory Excellence :  Monitor and ensure regulatory compliance and minimize complaints.
  • Hands-On Claims Management :  Oversee, evaluate, and authorize claims, keeping high priority  IN and PA PPA cases  closely monitored.
  • Guidance & Training :  Coach adjusters handling  IN and PA PPA claims  to meet or exceed service objectives and regulatory standards.
  • Negotiation & Resolution :  Negotiate claims, achieve favorable outcomes, and minimize expenses.
  • Build Relationships :  Foster collaboration within the Claims Department, working closely with staff, supervisors, and managers.
  • Continuous Improvement :  Identify opportunities to improve processes and ensure operational excellence.

What We're Looking For :

  • Bachelor’s degree or higher
  • Minimum 3 years of relevant claims management experience
  • IL, TN, or TX experience preferred and IN and / or PA experience strongly preferred
  • Nonstandard auto insurance experience a plus
  • Strong customer service skills and fast-track claim processing expertise
  • Skilled at negotiating with attorneys and pro se litigants
  • Knowledge of claims practices in IL, IN, TN, PA, or TX preferred
  • Exceptional written and verbal communication skills
  • Proficient with technology and coverage / liability analysis
  • High level of responsibility, problem-solving, and organizational skills
  • Bilingual Spanish preferred
  • Compensation & Benefits :

  • Base salary : $90,000 – $120,000
  • Performance bonus potential
  • 401(k) with up to 6% company match
  • Health & Wellness :

  • Blue Cross Blue Shield medical plans (PPO, HMO, HSA)
  • Dental and vision coverage
  • Growth & Stability :

  • Thirteen consecutive years of premium growth
  • Over 26 years of annual profitability
  • A+ “Superior” rating from A.M. Best
  • Professional Development :

  • Opportunities for advancement and training
  • Culture :

  • Business casual dress
  • Friendly, supportive workplace
  • Interested?

    Join AFIC to lead a high-performing claims team, focusing on  IN and PA PPA claims , while managing the overall workload across  IL, IN, TN, PA, and TX . Applications are accepted on an ongoing basis until the position is filled. Apply as soon as possible.

    Learn more :   www.americanfreedomins.com

    Company Description

    American Freedom Insurance Company (AFIC) is a midsized, profitable, and expanding nonstandard automobile insurance company doing business in Illinois, Indiana, Pennsylvania, Tennessee and Texas. We are looking for highly motivated, driven, and dedicated individuals to contribute in a fast paced, expanding organization.

    Company Description

    American Freedom Insurance Company (AFIC) is a midsized, profitable, and expanding nonstandard automobile insurance company doing business in Illinois, Indiana, Pennsylvania, Tennessee and Texas. We are looking for highly motivated, driven, and dedicated individuals to contribute in a fast paced, expanding organization.

    serp_jobs.job_alerts.create_a_job

    Insurance Manager • Mount Prospect, IL, US

    Job_description.internal_linking.related_jobs
    Auto Claims Leadership

    Auto Claims Leadership

    Warrior Insurance Network • Bedford Park, IL, USA
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    serp_jobs.filters_job_card.quick_apply
    Warrior Insurance Network is Growing!.Warrior Insurance Network (WIN) has experienced several years of significant growth and is poised to continue to grow in 2026 and beyond with an aggressive bus...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_variable_days
    Claims Manager, Excess Casualty

    Claims Manager, Excess Casualty

    Starrcompanies • Chicago, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    Excess Casualty Claims Manager.Starr Insurance Companies is a leading insurance and investment organization, providing commercial property and casualty insurance, including travel and accident cove...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_variable_days • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Auto Property Damage Claims Specialist

    Auto Property Damage Claims Specialist

    First Chicago Insurance Company (FCIC) • Oak Brook, IL, USA
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    serp_jobs.filters_job_card.quick_apply
    Are you unhappy at your present job?.Are you going nowhere in your current position?.Are you an experienced Auto Liability Claims Specialist looking to join a growing company where you will be rewa...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30
    Auto Property Damage Claims Specialist

    Auto Property Damage Claims Specialist

    Warrior Insurance Network • Oak Brook, IL, USA
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    serp_jobs.filters_job_card.quick_apply
    Are you unhappy at your present job?.Are you going nowhere in your current position?.Are you an experienced Auto Liability Claims Specialist looking to join a growing company where you will be rewa...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30
    Auto Claims Adjuster (Entry Level)

    Auto Claims Adjuster (Entry Level)

    Sedgwick • Naperville, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    Auto Claims Adjuster (Entry Level).This is an in-office role in either Scottsdale, AZ, Naperville, IL, or Indianapolis, IN. This is an entry-level role with an amazing training program for a high-le...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30 • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Claims Manager, Auto and General Liability

    Claims Manager, Auto and General Liability

    CNA • Chicago, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    You have a clear vision of where your career can go.And we have the leadership to help you get there.At CNA, we strive to create a culture in which people know they matter and are part of something...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_variable_days • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Auto Claims Leadership

    Auto Claims Leadership

    First Chicago Insurance Company (FCIC) • Bedford Park, IL, USA
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    serp_jobs.filters_job_card.quick_apply
    First Chicago Insurance Company is Growing!.First Chicago Insurance Company (FCIC), a member company of the Warrior Insurance Network, has experienced several years of significant growth and is poi...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_variable_days
    Claims Team Manager, General Liability (Construction)

    Claims Team Manager, General Liability (Construction)

    Zurich North America • Schaumburg, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    Claims Team Manager, General Liability (Construction).Deliver Results : Oversee the management of commercial general liability claims of moderate complexity by providing technical guidance, directio...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_variable_hours • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted • serp_jobs.job_card.new
    Manager, Group Claims

    Manager, Group Claims

    Chubb • Chicago, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    Focus on the core content of the job post, removing all extra metadata, navigation mentions, and redundant headers.Keep the formatting beautiful and high signal to noise ratio.serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30 • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Manager, Claims Services (Auto-PD)

    Manager, Claims Services (Auto-PD)

    IAT Insurance Group • Naperville, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    Manager, Claims Services (Auto-PD).The Casualty Claims department within IAT Insurance Group has an immediate opening for a Manager of Claims Services in our Auto-PD department.The Manager is a str...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30 • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Auto Property Damage Claims Director

    Auto Property Damage Claims Director

    First Chicago Insurance Company (FCIC) • Chicago, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    We are adding to our Auto Claims Leadership Team!!.The Auto Property Damage Director is responsible for oversight of the overall productivity and personnel of an Auto Property Damage Unit.Scope of ...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_variable_days • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Auto Liability Adjuster

    Auto Liability Adjuster

    Kemper • Downers Grove, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    Location(s) : P&C-Butterfield Road-Downers Grove-IL-AAC.We have an immediate opening for an experienced insurance professional with the ability to investigate and adjust first-party and third-party ...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30 • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Senior Auto Insurance Claims Adjuster - Hybrid (Office / Remote)

    Senior Auto Insurance Claims Adjuster - Hybrid (Office / Remote)

    American Freedom Insurance Company • Mount Prospect, IL, US
    serp_jobs.filters.remote
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    Senior Auto Insurance Claims Adjuster – Hybrid (Office / Remote).Are you passionate about problem-solving and delivering exceptional customer service? Do you thrive in fast-paced environments a...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30 • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Casualty Claims Manager

    Casualty Claims Manager

    Starrcompanies • Chicago, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    Starr Insurance Companies is a leading insurance and investment organization, providing commercial property and casualty insurance, including travel and accident coverage, to almost every imaginabl...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30 • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Claims Adjuster - Auto Damage - Lincolnshire, IL

    Claims Adjuster - Auto Damage - Lincolnshire, IL

    VetJobs • Lincolnshire, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    Claims Adjuster - Auto Damage - Lincolnshire, IL.Our organization works with partner companies to source qualified talent for their open roles. The following position is available to Veterans, Trans...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_variable_days • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Assurance Manager - Insurance

    Assurance Manager - Insurance

    RSM • Chicago, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    We are the leading provider of professional services to the middle market globally, our purpose is to instill confidence in a world of change, empowering our clients and people to realize their ful...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30 • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Claims Manager, Casualty

    Claims Manager, Casualty

    Starrcompanies • Chicago, IL, US
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    STARR is looking for individuals with "passion" and "drive" to join our team.There's no shortage of opportunities as we continue to grow. Alternate Locations : Atlanta, Philadelphia, Houston.The Clai...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30 • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted
    Senior General Liability Claims Specialist

    Senior General Liability Claims Specialist

    VirtualVocations • Naperville, Illinois, United States
    serp_jobs.job_card.full_time
    A company is looking for a Senior Commercial Auto and General Liability Claims Specialist.Key Responsibilities Manage mid to complex General Liability claims, including bodily injury and property...serp_jobs.internal_linking.show_more
    serp_jobs.last_updated.last_updated_30 • serp_jobs.job_card.promoted